• Blog
  • 2017
  • Smith Reports on 'Sixth Amendment-Free' Court Proceedings
Text Size:
Print This Page

Smith Reports on 'Sixth Amendment-Free' Court Proceedings

Click image to enlarge

Legal studies Chair Alisa Smith is the lead researcher and co-author of Rush to Judgment: How South Carolina's Summary Courts Fail to Protect Constitutional Rights,published this week by the National Association of Criminal Defense Attorneys.

The report documents the constitutional violations observed in five counties throughout South Carolina in the fall of 2015 and spring of 2016.

In the months of court watching and data collection, the researchers documented numerous findings, all of which are set forth in the Rush to Judgment report. They include:

  • A routine absence of any lawyers in the courtroom -- nearly 26% of observed defendants had their cases processed

    In the News
    Study Cites Due Process Violations in Low-level Courts as Charleston Officials Tout 'Groundbreaking' Improvement - Charleston Post and Courier, Jan. 21, 2017

    without interacting with a single lawyer: the case was prosecuted by a police officer, there was no defense counsel, andthe judge was not a licensed attorney.
  • Fewer than 10% of defendants in the study were represented by counsel. In 89% of the cases observed, the charging officers were the prosecutors in the summary court proceedings.
  • More than half of defendants (50.9%) were not advised of their right to counsel when speaking to the judge.
  • For bench trials, guilty was the most common verdict. Over 90% of defendants were found guilty; 96.3% of defendants tried in their absence were found guilty, compared to 73% when the defendant was present.

The report also suggests recommendations for reform. To access the full report, visit

For this study, Smith collaborated with University of Tampa Associate Professor Sean Madden and student observers from the University of South Carolina School of Law, Charleston School of Law, Yale Law School and others. 


Share and Enjoy:

Mentioned : Alisa Smith
Categories :


The health care informatics master's program at UCF really helped me connect with the industry, meet people at conferences and sit for the most-desired certification exams."
— Michael Neimann M.S. in health care informatics ('14)
My internship with the District 9 Medical Examiner’s Office was one of the greatest experiences of my life. I gained an excellent understanding of the medical examiner’s office and the criminal justice field in general."
— Adam Stubley B.S. in criminal justice, criminal profiling certificate ('11)
UCF provides its physical therapy students with an excellent education and prepares them to work in the most challenging of settings."
— Jamie Dyson Rehabilitation Supervisor, Orlando Regional Medical Center
UCF's program provided me the opportunity to expedite my student experience while attaining practical experience working within local health systems."
— Daniel Barr V.P. at National Children's Hospital; M.S. in health sciences, health services administration track ('04)
My master's education helped me see the big picture of the nonprofit industry. UCF showed me how to see the different fundraising tools within the Central Florida area."
— Krysti Griffith Executive Director of Growth from Grief; Master of Nonprofit Management ('12)
The course opened my eyes to grant writing ... I learned a great deal and you [Barbara Howell] are truly an excellent instructor."
— Deborah Reith Master of Public Administration student who secured a $10,000 federal grant through a course project; B.S. in criminal justice ('86)
The skills I learned during my time at UCF are what made my transition to law school so seamless."
— Jacqueline Iaquinta Touro Law Center student; B.S. in legal studies ('10)
As an inaugural graduate of the M.R.A. program at UCF, I can attest to the outstanding curriculum developed for research administrators. "
— April Heyward Post Award Services Coordinator, University of South Carolina; Master of Research Administration ('13)
It was at UCF that I first learned many of the skills that I’ve since honed, including mapping with GIS software - an ability I found invaluable to my search for internships, graduate-level coursework, and employment."
— Richard "Ben" Hagen Research and Communications Associate, New Economy Project, New York City; B.S. in public administration ('10)
I am excited to be able to give back to the program that invested so much in me. It is truly and honor and a privilege."
— Carlos Gual Instructor of Athletic Training; B.S. in athletic training ('09)
The faculty advisor [at my medical school] was amazed that I had the opportunity to truly participate in the full spectrum of research as an undergraduate. "
— Chase Cavayero, medical student at Lake Erie College of Osteopathic Medicince, B.S. in health sciences - pre-clinical ('13) 
Give a Gift - The College of Healh & Public Affairs